Gifted Education: A New Way To Look At Gifted Education
Your child reads years above grade level, asks endless questions, and melts down when the work is too easy — but the word “gifted” comes with its own baggage. The label can set a child apart, pile on pressure to be brilliant at everything, and make failure feel dangerous.
What if we’ve been asking the wrong question? Instead of “Is my child gifted?”, developmental psychologist Dr. Dona Matthews invites us to ask, “What does my child need to learn next — and how do we match it?” Her Optimal Match approach drops the label and meets every child at their actual learning needs, in each subject, at each moment in time.
Dr. Matthews is the founding director of the Hunter College Center for Gifted Studies and co-author of Being Smart About Gifted Learning. In this episode she explains why giftedness can ignite at any age, why it looks different in every subject, and what parents can do to feed a child’s curiosity without the pressure of a label.
Click on the link below to listen to the podcast or watch the YouTube video! 👇
LINKS MENTIONED IN THE RECORDING
https://theimpactfulparent.com/app
Download the FREE Impactful Parent App! Available on Apple and Android App Stores. FREEBIES from episodes included!
Apple Store: https://theimpactfulparent.com/ios
Android Play Store: https://theimpactfulparent.com/android
https://theimpactfulparent.com for more FREE Resources and paid programs.
What Do You Think?
Rate, Review, & Subscribe!
“I love Kristina and all the FREE tips that she has to offer! Thank you for making my parenting journey better!” <– If that sounds like you, please consider rating and reviewing my show! This helps me support more people — just like you!!! Rate with five stars, and select “Write a Review.” Then be sure to let me know what you loved most about the episode!
Also, if you haven’t done so already, subscribe to the podcast. I’m adding a bunch of bonus episodes to the feed and, if you’re not subscribed, there’s a good chance you’ll miss out. Subscribe now!
What to do next:
- Get The Impactful Parent App! Everything you need in your parenting journey in one spot! Available on the Android Play Store and the Apple Store. Search Impactful Parent (direct links listed above under Links in Episode).
- Follow The Impactful Parent on social media if you don’t already! Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, & Pinterest
- Subscribe to the PODCAST
- Check out the official website of The Impactful Parent for FREE RESOURCES, parenting classes, mom’s groups, and so much more! Click here to check it out!
- Discover how you can work with Kristina! Sign up for a FREE 30-minute discovery call! Click here to find a time that works best for you!
Bottom Line… I am here for YOU! Contact me at theimpactfulparent@gmail.com
TRANSCRIPT
Gifted Education: The Optimal Match — A New Way to Look at Gifted Learning
On this episode of The Impactful Parent, host Kristina Campos sat down with Dr. Dona Matthews — developmental psychologist, founding director of the Hunter College Center for Gifted Studies, and co-author (with Joanne Foster) of Being Smart About Gifted Learning. After decades of working with gifted children and their families, Dr. Matthews has come to a conclusion that surprises a lot of parents: the gifted label itself is often part of the problem. Her alternative is called the Optimal Match.
The Problem With the “Gifted” Label
The traditional approach to gifted education divides children into two categories: gifted and not gifted. Dr. Matthews has seen what that division does inside families — one child identified as gifted, a sibling who isn’t, and a whole set of issues that follow. Kristina agreed from her own experience: many gifted children don’t actually like the label. It sets them apart from the pack, and it comes with stigma and high expectations they never asked for.
The label also changes how a child relates to learning itself. A child who sees herself as “gifted” has something to defend. She may start avoiding high-level challenge, because failing at something hard feels like proof she doesn’t deserve the label. Perfectionism creeps in, and the love of learning that made her stand out in the first place quietly drains away.
What Is the Optimal Match?
The Optimal Match approach is simple to say and powerful in practice: match each child’s learning opportunities with their abilities — in a given area, at a given point in time. No categories, no segregation, no permanent identity to live up to. Just a continual question: what does this child need next?
Dr. Matthews gives the example of a third grader who is functioning at a ninth-grade level in math. That little girl is going to get into trouble in third-grade math class unless something is done to challenge her at her actual level. She will tune out, disengage, or start causing trouble — not because she is a problem, but because her learning needs aren’t being met. And she is never the only child in a school with that kind of gap. The answer is a wide range of learning options, available to kids with all kinds of abilities — including children with multiple exceptionalities.
The approach is grounded in what we now know about the brain. Neuroplasticity research shows that intelligence develops with opportunities to learn in a context of interest and motivation — true for every child. And it fits the growth mindset perspective: problems and failures are opportunities to learn more, not threats to an identity.
Giftedness Is Not All-or-Nothing
The traditional view assumes that if you’re gifted, you’re gifted at everything. The reality is that most of us have a variable profile of abilities — strong in one domain, ordinary in another, and those strengths can change over time. A child can also be gifted and have a learning disability at the same time. Twice-exceptional kids are exactly the ones who break the categorical model — and exactly the ones the Optimal Match is built to serve, because it looks at learning needs instead of labels.
Giftedness Can Ignite at Any Age
One of the most hopeful parts of this conversation: advanced learning needs can show up at any point. It might be the two-year-old reading proper books, years before “reading readiness” would ever interest her. Or it might be the teenager who coasts along unremarkably until one subject lights a fire. Kristina shared the story of her own son, who has dyslexia and never tested as gifted — “my gifted child that’s not gifted” — until a high school subject ignited him and he became an exceptional learner. Dr. Matthews points out that many of history’s highest achievers, including Nobel Prize winners and Albert Einstein, were not identified as gifted until university. Giftedness can be dormant. It can be ignited.
That is why Dr. Matthews recommends ongoing observation instead of one high-stakes test at one grade. Teachers who understand the Optimal Match stay vigilant from pre-kindergarten onward, watching for gifted learning needs the same way they watch for learning difficulties — and paying special attention to the very high achievers on standard tests, because a child at the 98th percentile might be right at grade level, or might be ten grades ahead. The test alone can’t tell you which.
What Parents Can Do Right Now
Dr. Matthews’ advice for parents starts at home. Pay attention to your child’s curiosity — that is always step one. Give them opportunities to engage in the area that fascinates them, and provide informal learning challenges at home where you can. Then look honestly at whether that curiosity is being supported at school.
Her strongest recommendation: treat your child’s teacher as your friend and collaborator. Teachers care about supporting kids’ optimal learning, and problem-solving together gets further than demanding. If nothing changes, find the other parents who feel the same way — one parent asking for something different can start a culture change, and two or three or five parents are much more likely to be heard. Schools that have adopted this perspective often got there because a parent spoke up.
The book behind this conversation, Being Smart About Gifted Learning, goes deeper on all of it — assessment, the science of the Optimal Match, and practical programming ideas for classrooms and homes, including homeschooling.
Key Takeaway to Remember
Your child doesn’t need a label to deserve the right challenge. Drop the question “Is my child gifted?” and ask instead, “What does my child need to learn next — and how do we match it?” Meet them where they are, feed their curiosity, and let them love learning without something to defend.
Keep reading:
- Do I Have A Gifted Child?
- Is My Child Gifted and Talented?
- Is My Child Smart or Lazy? Discover Giftedness in Children
This post is part of our Identity & Navigating Teen Culture guides — start there for every post and video on helping your child be themselves.